Monday, November 28, 2011
Do we need a land?
Usually religions evolve or start with an area of land. G-d brought Avraham away from his homeland, where there was already a religion. This seems strange to us and almost is a contradiction. Judaism is one of the few religions that absolutely does not revolve around land, but here we just learnt that Hashem took Avraham to the land that would eventually be ours. Does this mean Judaism is just another one of those religions that evolves around a piece of land? I don't think thats necessarily true. I think ultimately G-d knew we were going to get our own land and that is why he took Avraham to it in the first place. Even though it did not happen right away and there was much fighting involved to get to the ultimate goal, it was still gotten. I think this all goes back to last year when we had the debate about if G-d knowing the future is really giving us free will or not. G-d knows the outcome but lets us choose our own way to get there, or at least that's the way I think of it. I think G-d wanted Avraham to see where his future generations would live before he died so He took him there, how his future generations were going to get it, He didn't know.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I totally agree with Orly. I want to add that I think that the land is not essential for the survival of the religion. Instead, it is a beacon of hope for all of the Jewish people. Even at times when Jews did not have sovereignty in Eretz Yisrael, they fought and hoped and dreamed about a land where they could live in peace. Having the land would help Jews all over the world practice Judaism in a land of their own. This all started when Hashem led Avraham to the land that his children would one day inherit.
ReplyDeleteI think that G-d showing Avraham the land was like another act of reassurement for Avraham. When G-d told Avraham that He was going to maek his descendants into a great nation, He might have sensed a little doubt in Avraham. I mean, it isn't everydays that these kind of promises are made to him. To further reassure Avraham of His promise, G-d shows him the land where his descendents will live therefore making it more "real" for Avraham.
ReplyDelete